Want to discover 5 Exuma Islands for sale?

Exuma Islands, nestled in the heart of the Bahamas, represent a pristine paradise renowned for their crystalline waters, powdery white beaches, and lush tropical landscapes.

Comprising over 365 cays and islands, the Exumas offer unparalleled natural beauty and seclusion for those seeking a retreat from the ordinary.

In recent years, there has been a noticeable surge in the interest and acquisition of private islands worldwide.

The allure of owning a slice of secluded paradise has captivated the imaginations of affluent individuals, celebrities, and investors alike.

With the increasing desire for exclusivity and privacy, private island ownership has become a symbol of luxury and prestige.

This article aims to delve into the realm of private island ownership within the Exuma archipelago.

Specifically, we will showcase five exquisite Exuma islands currently available for sale, providing potential buyers with a glimpse into the extraordinary opportunities awaiting them in this tropical haven.

Whether you’re envisioning a tranquil retreat or an investment opportunity, these islands offer a rare chance to own a piece of paradise in one of the world’s most coveted destinations.

Exuma Islands: A Paradise for Private Ownership

exuma island

Situated in the translucent waters of the Bahamas, the Exuma Islands form an idyllic chain of cays and isles stretching across the aquamarine expanse of the Caribbean Sea.

Each island boasts its own unique charm, from the secluded beaches of Little Exuma to the vibrant marine life teeming around Great Exuma.

The region’s tropical climate, azure waters, and lush vegetation create an enchanting backdrop for those seeking a tranquil retreat or an exclusive escape.

The allure of owning a private island in Exuma lies in the unparalleled sense of seclusion, luxury, and freedom it offers.

Here, amidst the swaying palm trees and pristine shores, one can immerse themselves in the ultimate sanctuary away from the hustle and bustle of everyday life.

Whether it’s savoring the solitude of a deserted beach, exploring the underwater wonders of the surrounding reefs, or simply basking in the sun-kissed serenity, Exuma islands epitomize the epitome of tropical paradise.

Several factors contribute to the burgeoning demand for private islands in Exuma.

Firstly, the region’s breathtaking natural beauty and unspoiled landscapes captivate the imagination of discerning buyers seeking an escape from the ordinary.

Additionally, the exclusivity and prestige associated with owning a private island in such a coveted destination appeal to individuals who value privacy and seclusion.

Furthermore, the Bahamas’ favorable tax laws and stable political environment make it an attractive investment opportunity for both domestic and international buyers.

As a result, the demand for Exuma islands continues to rise, with a diverse range of buyers drawn to the allure of island living in one of the world’s most picturesque locales.

Factors to Consider When Buying an Exuma Island

exuma islands

A. Location and Accessibility

The location of an Exuma island plays a crucial role in its desirability and accessibility.

Considerations include proximity to mainland services, ease of travel to and from the island, and availability of transportation options such as airstrips or marinas.

Islands located closer to major hubs like Great Exuma may offer more convenience in terms of access to amenities and infrastructure.

B. Size and Topography of the Island

The size and topography of an Exuma island influence its potential for development and use.

Larger islands may offer more versatility in terms of building options, recreational spaces, and privacy.

Additionally, the topography of the island, including elevation, coastline, and natural features, can impact its aesthetic appeal and suitability for specific activities such as boating, snorkeling, or hiking.

C. Infrastructure and Amenities Available

When considering an Exuma island for purchase, it’s essential to assess the existing infrastructure and amenities available.

This includes access to utilities such as water and electricity, as well as the presence of existing structures or developments that may require maintenance or renovation.

Islands with established amenities such as docks, residences, and recreational facilities may offer added convenience and value to potential buyers.

D. Legal Considerations and Regulations

Navigating the legal landscape and regulatory framework is paramount when purchasing an Exuma island.

Buyers should conduct thorough due diligence regarding property ownership laws, zoning regulations, environmental restrictions, and any permits or approvals required for development or construction.

Engaging legal counsel familiar with Bahamian real estate laws can help ensure a smooth and compliant transaction process.

E. Environmental Impact and Sustainability

Preserving the natural environment and promoting sustainability are integral considerations when buying an Exuma island.

Assessing the ecological impact of proposed developments, implementing responsible land management practices, and adhering to conservation guidelines are essential for maintaining the island’s ecological integrity and long-term viability.

Buyers should prioritize sustainable design and development strategies that minimize carbon footprint, protect natural habitats, and promote eco-friendly practices.

Now, let’s take a closer look at 5 Exuma Islands for Sale:

1. Hummingbird Cay, Exuma Cays

Price: $53,312,490

Lot Size: 96 hectares

Hummingbird Cay, Exuma Cays

Nestled within the captivating Exuma Cays, Hummingbird Cay emerges as an exclusive Caribbean sanctuary, inviting investors to discover its unparalleled allure.

Spanning 237 acres, this private island encapsulates the essence of luxury amidst the breathtaking landscapes of the Exumas.

Envisioned as a pristine oasis, Hummingbird Cay boasts powdery white beaches, caressed by the turquoise embrace of the surrounding waters.

Its self-sustaining environment stands as a testament to sophistication and comfort, offering an array of amenities designed to elevate the island living experience.

The estate comprises two single-family residences, complemented by eight charming bungalows, commercial kitchens, dining halls, caretakers’ cottages, and storage facilities, among other amenities.

Notably, Hummingbird Cay features 2,500 feet of pristine shoreline at Sonova Beach, complemented by two additional private beaches, a boat harbor, boat dock, and boathouse.

Ensuring seamless connectivity, the island is equipped with satellite access and WiFi, fostering an environment where modern comfort meets natural splendor.

Its entirely self-sufficient and sustainable reverse osmosis system provides ample fresh water, while dedicated onsite crew members ensure the island operates smoothly.

Beyond its tangible assets, Hummingbird Cay embodies boundless potential, beckoning visionaries to transform its natural beauty into a captivating retreat.

With an ideal setting for a remarkable resort, the island offers limitless opportunities for curated experiences and recreational amenities, captivating the hearts of discerning travelers seeking an unforgettable escape.

Boasting a legacy of over 70 years under the ownership of the Bernhard family, renowned for their contributions to marine science and conservation, Hummingbird Cay exudes a timeless allure that defies description.

To truly grasp its magic, one must step ashore and embrace the transformative power of island living.

Accessible via seaplane or boat, Hummingbird Cay is conveniently located just 300 miles from Miami, Florida, and a mere 7 miles from the Great Exuma mainland.

Travelers can embark on a 15-minute boat ride from Great Exuma’s Mosstown dock in George Town or opt for a scenic seaplane journey from Miami, Florida, or Nassau, The Bahamas.

Hummingbird Cay stands as a testament to luxury, tranquility, and natural beauty—a haven where time stands still, and dreams take flight.

2. Nancy Skinner’s Cay

Price: $3,808,035

Lot Size: 16 hectares

Nancy Skinner's Cay

Nancy Skinner’s Cay emerges as a captivating investment opportunity, epitomizing the allure of private island ownership.

In an era where luxurious social distancing has become paramount, this enchanting enclave offers a secluded haven southwest of mainland Exuma and The Hermitage.

Spanning 38 acres, Nancy Skinner’s Cay boasts a blend of natural splendor and cultivable land, presenting a canvas ripe for exploration and development.

The island’s northern shoreline features an irregular terrain, ranging from 2 to fifteen feet high, enveloped by crystalline shallow waters and deep water channels.

On the southern side, a gentle slope descends to a marl and mangrove swash, accentuating the island’s diverse topography.

Noteworthy features include a diminutive cave with a distinctive mouth, perched 12 feet above H.W.M., nestled within a bluff at the northeast end of the cay.

Freshwater springs enrich the landscape, offering a sustainable resource amidst the island’s natural wonders.

Along the western portion, a shallow water body with a deep channel meanders through the cay and neighboring isles to the south, enhancing the maritime allure of Nancy Skinner’s Cay.

Strategically positioned in close proximity to mainland Exuma, Nancy Skinner’s Cay affords convenient access while preserving the privacy coveted by discerning buyers.

Additionally, the island presents an enticing opportunity for investors, as it is offered in conjunction with a 52-acre parcel at The Hermitage (MLS #44607) on mainland Exuma, catering to the astute investor seeking diversified real estate ventures.

Nancy Skinner’s Cay beckons with its promise of serenity, seclusion, and untapped potential—a testament to the enduring allure of private island living in one of the Bahamas’ most coveted locales.

3. Big Bullard Cay, Southwest Of Great Exuma, Exuma Cays

Price: $2,284,821

Lot Size: 40 hectares

Big Bullard Cay

Big Bullard Cay, also referred to as Goat Cay or Mrs. Bullard’s Goat Cay, stands as a picturesque private island offering breathtaking vistas and boundless potential.

Nestled along the southwestern coast of Great Exuma, this captivating enclave epitomizes the allure of island living in the Exuma Cays.

Situated merely 400 feet from the southeastern tip of Deadman’s Cay on the mainland, Big Bullard Cay enjoys a close proximity to mainland Great Exuma.

A deep channel delineates the southeastern boundary, creating a natural division between the cay and the mainland.

Along the southern perimeter, shallow waters give way to expansive stretches of marl and mangroves, accentuating the island’s diverse coastal landscape.

Crab Cay, a neighboring isle, graces the southeastern coast of Great Exuma, further enhancing the scenic allure of the region.

Of the 96.73 acres comprising Big Bullard Cay, a portion is available for sale, while the remainder is designated as Crown Land, preserving the island’s natural splendor and ecological integrity.

Access to the island is facilitated by a designated lot on Deadman’s Cay, offering the potential for constructing a dock and enhancing connectivity to the mainland.

With its pristine surroundings and strategic location, Big Bullard Cay presents an unparalleled opportunity for discerning buyers seeking to embrace the tranquility and seclusion of private island living in the Exuma Cays.

4. Roberts Cay, Private Island

Price: $7,996,873

Lot Size: 5 hectares

Roberts Cay

Roberts Cay stands as an exquisite private island nestled within the northern chain of the Exuma Cays, offering a sanctuary of unparalleled beauty and serenity.

Encompassing 12 acres of verdant landscapes adorned with lush green vegetation, this idyllic enclave beckons with its pristine shores, protected harbor, and elevated terrain reaching approximately 32 feet above sea level.

Embraced by crystal-clear turquoise waters, Roberts Cay is a haven for aquatic adventures, with opportunities for snorkeling along the harbor side and deep-sea fishing off the eastern shores.

Its two white sandy beaches epitomize the quintessential Caribbean escape, providing a tranquil retreat amidst the breathtaking expanse of the Exuma Cays.

Conveniently located approximately 28 miles southeast of Nassau, Roberts Cay enjoys a strategic position half a mile south of Ship Channel Cay, with easy access to nearby destinations such as Norman’s Cay and Highbourne Cay.

Whether seeking solace amidst nature’s embrace or envisioning a bespoke retreat, Roberts Cay offers an ideal canvas to realize your dreams of a private oasis in the heart of the Bahamas.

5. Leaf Cay

Price: $27,410,235

Lot Size: 5 hectares

leaf cay

Leaf Cay emerges as a captivating freehold private island, spanning 15 acres of pristine beauty and tranquility amidst the spectacular Exumas Island chain of the Bahamas Archipelago.

Situated at the heart of this breathtaking region, Leaf Cay boasts three mesmerizing white sand beaches, inviting residents to embrace the epitome of island living.

Conveniently positioned just 2 miles east of Staniel Cay, Leaf Cay enjoys seamless connectivity to the main power grid of the Bahamas Electric Company via an insulated, underwater cable originating from Staniel Cay.

This strategic location places the island within close proximity to Staniel Cay’s public 3,000-foot runway, facilitating commercial flights from South Florida and Nassau, thereby ensuring effortless access for residents and visitors alike.

Leaf Cay holds a coveted position within the Exumas, offering unparalleled convenience and accessibility to nearby amenities and attractions.

With approval in principle for a resort development, the island presents an exceptional opportunity for investors seeking to curate a distinctive hospitality experience.

The proposed development includes plans for eight condominiums, seven villas, sixteen overwater bungalows, a 30-slip marina, and a helipad, catering to the discerning tastes of modern travelers.

Existing infrastructure on the island comprises nineteen buildings, houses, a dock, storage areas, roads, underground utilities, construction equipment, workshops, and materials, providing a foundation for potential restoration or renovation endeavors.

Leaf Cay’s strategic location, a mere 2 miles west of Staniel Cay, ensures seamless access via a short 5-minute boat ride, while its proximity to Nassau and Great Exuma underscores its desirability as a premier island destination.

Leaf Cay embodies the essence of exclusivity and luxury in a coveted location—a testament to the unparalleled allure of private island living in the heart of the Exumas.


Throughout the Exuma archipelago, private islands beckon with their pristine beaches, turquoise waters, and lush landscapes, offering a slice of paradise unlike any other.

From secluded retreats to potential resort developments, the allure of Exuma islands for sale lies in their unparalleled beauty and endless possibilities.

For those captivated by the dream of owning a private island, the Exuma Cays present a myriad of options waiting to be discovered.

With each island boasting its own unique charm and potential, interested buyers are encouraged to explore the diverse offerings available, from untouched paradises to turnkey retreats.

Owning a private island in Exuma represents the epitome of exclusivity and luxury, offering a retreat from the ordinary and a sanctuary for the soul.

Whether seeking solitude amidst nature’s embrace or envisioning a curated resort experience, Exuma islands embody the promise of escape, adventure, and limitless potential.

In the heart of the Caribbean, amidst the shimmering waters of the Bahamas, Exuma islands await those bold enough to embrace their magic.

As the sun sets over the horizon and the gentle waves lull the shores to sleep, the allure of private island ownership in Exuma endures—a testament to the enduring allure of paradise found.

exuma islands for sale

(Island Expert)

Christian is a dynamic serial entrepreneur and a licensed real estate agent with a relentless passion for unlocking the potential of island real estate.Christian's expertise extends beyond entrepreneurship and property transactions.He possesses a profound expertise in crafting captivating content and persuasive copywriting tailored exclusively to the enchanting realm of island real estate.

Thanks for your enquiry.

Check your email shortly for the ebook download link.

Download Island Buyers Guide Ebook

Please fill in your details below and we will send you this ebook via email